US Elections

Follow the 2012 Presidential Candidates on  YouTube Follow the 2012 Presidential Candidates on Twitter Follow the 2012 Presidential Candidates on Twitter

Libertarian Candidates  Age & Birthdate
Libertarian Candidates  Ancestry
Libertarian Candidates  Books
Libertarian Candidates  Careers
Libertarian Candidates  Education
Libertarian Candidates  Military Service
Libertarian Candidates  Parents & Grandparents
Libertarian Candidates  Religion
Libertarian Candidates  Spouses
Compare Libertarian Candidates  Abortion
Compare Libertarian Candidates  Afghanistan
Compare Libertarian Candidates  Budget
Compare Libertarian Candidates  Business and Labor
Compare Libertarian Candidates  Civil Liberties
Compare Libertarian Candidates  Economy
Compare Libertarian Candidates  Education
Compare Libertarian Candidates  Environment
Compare Libertarian Candidates  Foreign Affairs
Compare Libertarian Candidates  Gun Control
Compare Libertarian Candidates  Health Care
Compare Libertarian Candidates  Immigration
Compare Libertarian Candidates  Iraq
Compare Libertarian Candidates  Marijuana
Compare Libertarian Candidates  National Security
Compare Libertarian Candidates  Same Sex / LGBT
Compare Libertarian Candidates  Social Security
Compare Libertarian Candidates  Taxes
Libertarian Candidates  Computer Literacy
Libertarian Candidates  Heroes
Libertarian Candidates  TV and Movies

  Republican Convention
    Chris Christie
    Rick Santorum
    Ann Romney
    Ted Cruz
    Mike Huckabee
    Condoleezza Rice
    Paul Ryan
    Clint Eastwood
    Jeb Bush
    Marco Rubio
    Mitt Romney
  Democratic Convention
    Debbie Wasserman Schultz
    Rahm Emmanuel
    Julian Castro
    Michelle Obama
    Sandra Fluke
    Elizabeth Warren
    Bill Clinton
    Caroline Kennedy
    John Kerry
    Jill Biden
    Joe Biden
    Barack Obama


I. Social Security In Five Minutes
II. FICA Contributions and Disbursements - Historical Data
III. Criticisms
♦ Sustainability
♦ Empty Trust Funds
IV. Trivia

The Civil War Pension
Some argue that the 1861 Civil War Pension program was, in fact, the country's first social insurance program. It was initially intended to provide protection for soldiers who were disabled as a direct physical consequence of active combat. The Civil War Pension program was expanded in 1873 to include benefits for widows and dependents, in cases of death. A new proviso was added to the program in 1890 in the form of the Dependent Pension Act, which expanded the coverage to old age (including for widows and children, in cases of death). At its peak in 1894, the program provided coverage to nearly 2.5 million Americans and accounted for 37% of the federal budget.
(i) Former Confederate soldiers were excluded from the program.
(ii) Two children of Civil War vets continue to receive benefits under the Civil War Pension program to this day, 147 years after the end of the Civil War.

I. Social Security In Five Minutes

President Franklin Delano Roosevelt signed the Social Security Act into law on August 14, 1935, and the Social Security Board (the precursor to the Social Security Administration) was officially established on October 14, 1936.

The Board, and subsequently, the Social Security Administration, operates under the terms outlined under Title 42 of the U.S.C.

Widely referred to as the Economic Security Bill during the drafting stages, the Social Security Act came into being in the wake of the Great Depression and the resulting economic turmoil, which saw more than half of the nation's 7.8 million senior citizens living below the poverty line. The bill was designed to prevent a similar recurrence through the creation of a federally mandated insurance program that would provide income to retirees age 65 and above.

The Act initially faced fierce resistance from Republican legislators, who felt that the program was inherently socialistic in nature. However, the proposal proved to be popular with Americans at large, leading to a swift passage through both the House (371-33) and Senate (77-6).

The Act was amended to expand its coverage in 1939 (spouses and children), 1956 (the disabled and their beneficiaries), 1965 (Medicare, for twelve years before it fell under the jurisdiction of the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services) and 1972 (Supplemental Security Income, but funded by federal tax revenues, not Social Security taxes).

Social Security is funded principally through the Federal Insurance Contributions Act (FICA), a compulsory form of employment tax legislated according to the stipulations contained within Title 26 of the U.S.Code (below, left). Deposits are managed by the Federal Old-Age and Survivors Insurance Trust Fund and the Federal Disability Insurance Trust Fund, under the supervision of the Board of Trustees of the Trust Funds, as outlined in Title 42, Chapter 7, Subchapter II, Section 401 (c) of the U.S.Code.

The Board of Trustees "shall be composed of the Commissioner of Social Security, the Secretary of the Treasury, the Secretary of Labor, and the Secretary of Health and Human Services... and of two members of the public (both of whom may not be from the same political party), who shall be nominated by the President for a term of four years and subject to confirmation by the Senate."

The six-man board is mandated to present an annual report to the Congress no later than the first day of April each year.

As of 2009, 453.7 million Americans have been registered with the Social Security Administration.

Since 1937, the agency has received contributions amounting to $13.87 trillion and disbursed $11.33 trillion.

Today, more than 30 million retirees, five million disabled Americans and about ten million beneficiaries receive support from the Social Security Administration.

II. FICA Contributions and Disbursements - Historical Data

III. Criticisms


There are concerns that Social Security, in its current form, is unsustainable.

The imminent and ongoing retirement of the baby boomers' generation is expected to outpace the entry of young Americans into the workforce.

Further, the consistently rising life expectancy of average Americans entails a longer coverage period.

As it is now, there have been an almost 25% growth of Americans aged 60 years and above in the last decade alone.

Under these circumstances, it is feared that the Administrations' two and a half trillion dollars surplus will rapidly diminish.

Empty Trust Funds

In its 77 year history, the Social Security Administration has stashed away a surplus amounting to $2,540,348,000,000, a figure that easily ensures its solvency for at least two decades. The $2.5 trillion surplus is deposited into a trust fund held by, wait for it, the federal government - the very same federal government that is currently almost $16 trillion in debt.

Analysts have been speculating since the early 1990s that the federal government has been dipping their hands into the Old-Age and Survivors Insurance Trust Fund (OASI) and the Disability Insurance Trust Fund (DI), despite repeated denials from four consecutive American administrations.

Dr. Allen W. Smith's 2003 book, The Looting of Social Security: How the Government is Draining America's Retirement Account, accused the George H. W. Bush and Bill Clinton administrations of spending the entire trust fund on government programs. Dr. Allen also charged that the federal government's "$2.5 trillion debt to Social Security is the real reason that so many politicians want to cut benefits. They are trying to find a way to avoid having to repay the looted money."

The Associated Press also ran a critical piece on March 14, 2010, which accused Congress "of raiding the Social Security trust funds to pay for other programs, masking the size of the budget deficit."

Washington Post's Charles Krauthammer perhaps explained the situation best in an article last year.

"When your FICA tax is taken out of your paycheck, it does not get squirreled away in some lockbox in West Virginia where it's kept until you and your contemporaries retire. Most goes out immediately to pay current retirees, and the rest (say, $100) goes to the U.S. Treasury - and is spent. On roads, bridges, national defense, public television, whatever - spent, gone.

In return for that $100, the Treasury sends the Social Security Administration a piece of paper that says: IOU $100. There are countless such pieces of paper in the lockbox. They are called "special issue" bonds. Special they are: They are worthless."

The ruse finally came into the open during the debt ceiling crisis in 2011. Speaking to CBS' Scott Pelley on July 12, 2011, President Obama indicated that failure to increase the federal debt ceiling may prevent the government from mailing out Social Security checks. The implication was obvious; the federal government could only meet its obligation (to Social Security, among others) if it was allowed to borrow.
Pelley: Can you tell the folks at home that no matter what happens, the Social Security checks are gonna go out on August the third? There are about $20 billion worth of Social Security checks that have to go out the day after the government is supposedly gonna go into default?

Mr. Obama: Well, this is not just a matter of Social Security checks. These are veterans' checks, these are folks on disability, and their checks. There are about 70 million checks that go out each month.

Pelley: Can you guarantee, as president, those checks will go out on August the third?

Mr. Obama: I cannot guarantee that those checks go out on August 3rd if we haven't resolved this issue. Because there may simply not be the money in the coffers to do it.

IV. Trivia

Trivia 1: The Social Security Board issued its first ever Social Security number to 23-year old John D. Sweeney, Jr., of New Rochelle, New York, on December 1, 1936 (SSN 055-09-0001)

Trivia 2: Ms. Grace D. Owen of Concord, New Hampshire, was the recipient of the lowest possible Social Security number (SSN 001-01-0001). However, owing to logistics and the geographic distribution of numbers, her registration was approved well after Mr. Sweeney.

Trivia 3: Ms. Ida May Fuller of Brattleboro, Vermont, became the first American to receive a monthly Social Security check. She was issued a check in the amount of $22.54 on January 31, 1940.



2012 Libertarian Presidential Nominee
Former Governor of New Mexico

Gary Johnson

Presidential Candidate Gary Johnson

Johnson Position on Social Security

Governor Johnson believes that Social Security is inherently flawed at conception, and similar to Ron Paul, believes that it has now turned into a Ponzi scheme.

Johnson considers Social Security as one of the most important items on his agenda of reform, and believes that privatization, with an option to cede control to individual account holders, is the programs’ best bet for maintaining its solvency.
Well I think social security has to be reformed. And I think at a minimum the retirement age needs to be raised. I’m talking about privatizing social security or being allowed to self-direct your social security account. I think it needs to be part of the mix

I would love to have had that when I was a 17 year old paying into the social security system.
By the way today I would still opt for 100%, to be, for me, to be able to self-direct 100% of my social security funds. There also needs to be some means testing going forward, on what gets paid in, what goes, gets paid out.

If we don’t reform all this areas, I think we’re gonna be left with nothing. We have a chance here to take a little bit of medicine, perhaps live on, and I’m talking about the United States of America.

But if we don’t address these problems, we might be all left with nothing and that nothing will be a dollar that doesn’t buy us anything tomorrow.
Oct 27, 2010: Johnson in an interview with Rob Nikolewski

“Social Security is flawed. When it was brought into existence the life expectancy was 55. Benefits started at 65. Now, life expectancy is 75, and benefits start at about the same age. It’s a Ponzi scheme. A combination of benefit reduction and/or privatization are necessary. At least part of Social Security should include private accounts that are counted in your estate.”
January 19, 2010: Interview with the Republican Liberty Caucus

More on Johnson  

Support our website with Google Plus

Comment on Social Security

    © 2007-2012
About Us Terms & Conditions Privacy Policy Contact Us 2016 Candidates